
This time last year we were saying it was a one-horse race in the Premier League after Manchester City’s storming start. So to say it’s a two-horse race now, with Manchester United thrown in, is ridiculous.
There was a mini-capitulation last season with City’s defence and I’m not sure Pep Guardiola has completely sorted out those problems. Yet.
I’ve not seen a vast improvement in all the players to show that so far, but that is not a strength of Guardiola – he doesn’t look to spend too much time on his defence, it’s more about his attacking side. We all know they haven’t been tested yet – they hammered Liverpool and Watford of course, but they also drew with Everton and beat Bournemouth with a late goal.
‘Toure could cause a problem in a phone box’
Anything can happen with their squad – Sergio Aguero could get injured so they’ll need someone to step in and do a job for the whole season. And what about the contentment of the big stars if certain personalities aren’t playing? They’ve still got Yaya Toure in there and we know he’s a sulker. Generally the squad is happy when they are winning but Toure doesn’t care – he could cause a problem in a phone box.
You are also ruling out the other big teams after just five games. Somewhere along the line, Tottenham have to click into gear. They cannot keep using the hoodoo of Wembley as an excuse. Arsenal have shown a little bit more resilience so far, so they will take points off other teams, like they did at the weekend with Chelsea.
Manchester City’s Leroy Sane and Yaya Toure on the substitutes benchReuters
Liverpool will have to sort out their defence – we know what their major problem is. Yes, it was 1-1 against Burnley on Saturday, but we saw Manchester United do something similar last season with the number of draws they had. I think Liverpool can still fix it.
Then you have champions Chelsea. You look at their side and you think ‘yes, they could do it again’ but they have to sort out their discipline. It was worrying what happened at the weekend, with David Luiz getting sent off against Arsenal – their fifth red card in eight games.
In general, though, there are too many points to play for to call it just a two-horse race.
United are the most complete team
However, if you are asking who is more likely to win the league out of the Manchester clubs at the moment, then it’s United for the simple reason that teams are wondering how to beat them.
Jose Mourinho will stop teams – including City – from playing and it is up to the likes of Guardiola to find another way. It’s easier to destroy then create.
United are finishing off sides in the last 10-15 minutes, so even when they tide isn’t going their way, they can flip it very quickly because of the pace and the strength that they now have in their frontline.
City can attack better than any team in the Premier League – they can do things off the cuff and there is a pattern in what they are trying to do. But we know they still don’t have many good one-on-one defenders. United have got better 1one-on-one defenders, more wholehearted, 100 per cent players in those positions – rather than attacking options like City. A solid back four will give you more chance of winning the league, simple as that.
In fact, United are way above any other side in all areas – the four departments of the team.
We’ve mentioned the defence and you saw with the goalkeeper, David De Gea, making some great saves against Everton when United were 1-0 up. They also have Romelu Lukaku, a bulldozer, through the middle, who is quick and clinical as well (even if he did miss a sitter at the weekend). And there are others in the forwards like Marcus Rashford, Juan Mata and Anthony Martial that they can pull in to give them the edge in the final third. They’ve got that little bit of quality when it’s needed now.
They’ve also invested in the players in the midfield – because it is Manchester United the money has come into it.
‘I never played against a winger’
As for Mourinho saying it’s a defensive Premier League, United are as defensive as any team. But the difference is they have the pace up front to run in behind other sides.
Manchester United’s Portuguese manager Jose Mourinho gestures on the touchline during the English Premier League football match between Manchester United and Everton at Old Trafford in Manchester, north west England, on September 17, 2017.Getty Images
So if teams change formations or the way they play when they are facing United, they are not being defensive, they are being respectful. When you are playing Barcelona, you don’t think you can go toe-to-toe with them, you have to put up a bit of a wall. You go a little bit negative, it’s human nature.
Teams are definitely more fearful of United now – it was like that under Sir Alex Ferguson. People used to ask me ‘Who was the best winger you played against?’ But I replied: ‘I never played against a winger because they were always backtracking on Andrei Kanchelskis. On the other side, Denis Irwin had the same, the opposition were trying to contain Lee Sharpe or Ryan Giggs.’
That wasn’t teams being negative, it was giving you respect. So let’s stop this rubbish about teams playing defensively in the league – they are giving United the respect they deserve.
@realpaulparker2


